This post summarizes an October 2024 episode of Y Combinator’s Design Review, where Stripe’s Head of Design, Katie Dill, reviews user-submitted startup websites with host Aaron Epstein. In the episode she is introduced as Stripe’s head of design, formerly head of design at Lyft and head of experience design at Airbnb. The feedback below is hers and the host’s, on five sites: Mito Health, SigNoz, Taiv, Metriport and AminoAnalytica. It is one designer’s opinion on each site, not tested conversion data.
Key Takeaways #
- First Impressions Matter: The initial look of a website can set the tone for user engagement.
- Clarity Is Key: Say what the product is and who it is for. If you have to tell users how to use the page, that is a bad sign.
- Visual Hierarchy: Properly structured information helps users understand the value proposition quickly.
- User-Centric Design: Ask users how they would describe the product, and watch them use the site, instead of guessing.
The Importance Of First Impressions #
Katie emphasized that the first impression a user gets from a website is crucial. For instance, when reviewing Mito Health, her first reaction was that the site felt more foreboding about your future health than uplifting. She said she did not know whether that was intentional. A site should show visitors why they should be there, because, in her words, they have other things to do.
Clarity And Navigation #
When it comes to navigation, Katie pointed out that users should not have to be told how to interact with a site. For example, Mito’s “scroll to explore” prompt drew the comment that it is never a good sign if you have to tell people how to use the page. The hosts also disliked that the site hijacks the scroll. Her point: it is a website, so people should know what to do without instructions.
Visual Hierarchy And Information Structure #
Katie discussed the importance of visual hierarchy in web design. Users often scan websites rather than read every word. Therefore, the most critical information should be easily accessible. For instance, Mito’s line about blood work and personalized insights to help you live healthier and longer came only after a lot of scrolling. The hosts wondered why the site did not start there. They also noted the page showed a 21-year-old as the example customer next to a photo of an older man, which muddied who the site was for. Starting with something concrete about what it is and who it is for was their suggestion.
Engaging Users With Visuals #
The use of visuals can enhance user engagement, but they must add value. For example, SigNoz had a product shot right at the top that gave Katie a sense of what the product is. She also liked that the video’s thumbnail itself was useful. However, she said the page then had a lot going on and a lot of different type sizes, and asked whether every pixel is adding value.
Understanding Your Audience #
Katie stressed asking your users how they would describe your product. For Taiv, she doubted that “give your TV superpowers” is how its users think about the product. The line under it, which says it enhances live TV in restaurants to increase revenue, made it clear to her that restaurant owners are the audience, but she had to read it to get there. She also pointed out inconsistent casing in the page text, and said such small details can erode trust.
The Role Of Trust In Design #
Trust came up repeatedly. On SigNoz she said recognizing many of the customer logos helps build trust and credibility. She also said unexplained or inconsistent details, such as inconsistent casing, can make users wonder what else you are not on top of. For Metriport, she and the host said the value proposition was clear (“I think they nailed that”). Their critiques were about the blob animation (what is it communicating, and do its lines get cut off?), busy product cards, and CTAs that compete with the main “book demo” CTA.
Balancing Fun And Professionalism #
The founders of AminoAnalytica asked whether a fun, B2C-style site can work for a traditional corporate B2B engineering company. Katie said absolutely you can be fun in B2B, and she liked the energetic color. Her caution was about when it starts eroding usability: the logo was hard to read, the type was busy, and the page did not make clear who it is for or why to trust the company. Her advice: don’t lose the fun, but make it communicate better.
Conclusion #
Katie Dill’s comments in this episode come back to a few questions: does the page say what the product is and who it is for, does every element add value, and what do real users say when they look at it? Her advice on conversion for SigNoz was to listen to users and map the journey that got them to the page. Her phrase for the rest is that every pixel should add value.





